Sunday, / December 21, 2025
Home / news

Do Menorahs Belong in the Public Square?

The public menorah has become a ubiquitous symbol at shopping malls, parks and public spaces the world over. But arguments over holiday displays and the religious nature of their symbols have been waged in town halls, on city boards and have even reached the Supreme Court.

From our archives, Lubavitch.com presents two articles that look at the legal history of the Menorah in the Public Square.

A 2006 piece, written eighteen years after the Allegheny vs ACLU ruling, explores the menorah as a symbol of religious freedom and whether the precedent set by the ruling has helped Chabad’s public menorah campaign.

In 2014, Dovid Zaklikowski opened his article with a quote from then-Vice President Joe Biden comparing “the ongoing miracle of coming together in a nation that respects the freedom to live and worship in peace,” to the battle the Macabees fought “long, long ago.” And takes us back to the first public Menorah lighting on a Manhattan street in the early 70s.

Click here to find a public Menorah lighting near you.

Comment 4
  • Karen Mandel

    If we are celebrating Christmas with Christmas trees and Christmas ornaments. Then there is no reason why can’t we have a Hanukkah Manila.

  • Neil F McAuley

    As a Roman Catholic, I wish there were more menorahs in view in public here in the U.K. and more Christmas nativity scenes allowed in public spaces… live, let live, love and celebrate!

  • Yes they belong in public, just like the cross.

  • I don’t believe ANY religious displays belong in public spaces. All the Christian displays are offensive; added Jewish ones doesn’t make them any more acceptable.

Add

Related Articles
Germany: Light in the Footprint of Hate
As a light drizzle fell, thousands gathered for a historic Menorah lighting in Berlin, Germany. “I just watched a light extinguish a dark history at…
Public Jewish Hour: 88 Years, Going Strong
It’s Wednesday afternoon and young men are streaming out of the yeshivah on Brooklyn’s leafy Eastern Parkway. Armed with snacks, crafts, and sheafs of paper,…
A Little Boy Who Lit up His Town
“Why is there no menorah in Chadwick Lake Park next to the tree?” five-year-old Brandon asked. His Dad was impressed by the kid's thoughtfulness, but…
How Las Vegas’ Dancing Dreidels Became a Chanukah Phenomenon
They march onto NFL fields, get booked by news stations, mobbed by fans, and chased by lines of selfie-seekers — and no, they’re not influencers.…
How To Chanukah
The Menorah On each of the eight nights of Chanukah, this year beginning December 14 through December 22, we light the menorah. Here, in a…
In the Snow or the Sun, Chabad’s Chanukah Celebrations Share Light and Joy
As frigid temperatures and snowstorms pummel much of the United States, Jewish communities will share the warmth of Chanukah at Chabad’s public menorah lightings. In…
Newsletter
Donate
Find Your Local Chabad Center
Magazine